The director of the Maryland State Boychoir has resigned after he was identified as one of the 156 Catholic Church staff named in a Maryland Attorney General’s Office report on child sex abuse in the Archdiocese of Baltimore.
The Baltimore Sun on Friday named Frank T. Cimino Jr. as one of 10 alleged abusers whose names were redacted in a public version of the report issued April 5.
Cimino, 75, founded the boychoir 36 years ago and served as its president and director emeritus. Now numbering about 130 members, it performs widely in the state, nationally and abroad.
“This painful set of circumstances was completely unexpected, and to our knowledge, there have never been any previous complaints about Mr. Cimino’s conduct,” the choir’s board of directors wrote in an email Saturday to its community. “The entire Board understands how surprising and concerning this must be as the allegations made against Mr. Cimino occurred long before the Maryland State Boychoir was established. The Board shares your sentiments.”
In recent weeks, others identified as being in the report have been put on leave from parish ministry, resigned from a hospital board and had a transfer to a new parish canceled.
The choir’s board appointed its artistic director, Stephen Holmes, to take over for Cimino as acting president, the email said.
The Sun reported Cimino was fired in 1987 from his job as minister of music at St. Thomas More Catholic Church in Northeast Baltimore after a man reported that he had been sexually abused by him as a choirboy in the 1970s. Archdiocese officials confronted Cimino with the allegations, and he denied them, according to the attorney general’s report. The report said the man reported the sexual abuse again in 2020.
Cimino started the boychoir the same year he was fired from St. Thomas More.
The news of his inclusion in the report prompted the choir’s board to convene “to discuss the matter and organizational leadership,” and Cimino resigned effective immediately, according to the email.
“The Maryland State Boychoir will continue to monitor and evaluate this situation and pledges to update you as appropriate,” the email said. “Lastly, there is nothing more important than the emotional and physical safety of our choristers, and everyone in our community. We remain committed to our future and advancing our very important mission.”
Cimino began the choir with just 14 boys who would practice in his mother’s basement. It grew from there, recording several CDs and performing everywhere from the White House to the Vatican.
The late Gov. William Donald Schaefer named the group an official goodwill ambassador of the state, and it performed at his funeral.
The choir eventually came to be based at St. Matthew United Church of Christ in the Northeast Baltimore neighborhood of Mayfield, where Cimino serves as organist and music minister. The choir bought the church building in 2006.
On Sunday, Cimino led singers of a range of ages in a rehearsal before the morning service. When asked for comment, he said he didn’t have time.
The Sun briefly spoke with several congregation members, who said they did not know about the allegations against Cimino. Those who were aware said they knew little and did not want to discuss it.
The Rev. Jill Snodgrass, who officiated, did not mention Cimino. She encouraged attendees to come forward and share their prayer requests, and one man said that when controversy “swirls around” that “we need to remember we are a family.”
Pastor Eugene P. Bartell, who has since retired, spoke late in the service and asked the congregation to pray for Cimino, whom he called “one of the brightest and strongest” in the congregation. He said Cimino has nurtured the choir and its choristers and wished that the church would pour down love and peace on him.
“Frank’s spirit has been tested in these last couple days,” Bartell said. “We love him. … Thank God for the precious life of Frank Cimino.”
With the revelation of Cimino as No. 147 on the attorney general’s “List of Abusers” in its report, only one remains unidentified, a nun who served for two years in the 1940s.
Since the report was published nearly two months ago, The Sun has reviewed thousands of pages of court records, decades of archdiocese directories, and dozens of contemporary newspaper articles to piece together details that helped reveal the identities of those whose names were redacted.
On Wednesday, The Sun identified the Rev. Thomas Hudson, an Episcopal minister, as No. 150 in the report. He was a public schoolteacher in Frederick in the mid-70s and was active at St. John Catholic Church there. The report said he gave a 15-year-old boy alcohol on a camping trip and tried to take the youth’s pants off.
Hudson has taken a leave of absence from his church, St. George in Allegany County.
In a letter late Thursday to Episcopalians in the Diocese of Maryland, Episcopal Bishop Eugene Taylor Sutton reiterated what he told The Sun earlier in the day: that he directed Hudson to go on leave after learning of the details of his case from the newspaper’s coverage.
“The Bible tells us we are all created in the image of God. In Holy Baptism, we promise to serve Christ in all persons, and to strive for justice and peace. When we become aware of situations where we have failed to recognize the image of God in others, we are compelled to act on that awareness,” Sutton wrote.
He also said the Episcopal diocese and church “are committed to holding each other accountable through our Church canon law and ecclesiastical disciplinary process.”
The Sun has also revealed the names of five high-ranking Catholic archdiocese officials, referred to in the report as Officials A through E, who, according to the attorney general’s findings, helped cover up the abuse.
Among them is Msgr. Richard “Rick” Woy, Official B, currently pastor of St. Elizabeth Ann Seton in Crofton. The day after The Sun article named him, he resigned from the board of directors of the University of Maryland St. Joseph Medical Center. A previous effort to oust him from the Towson hospital’s board after he was featured in the 2017 Netflix documentary, “The Keepers,” failed.
Another of the officials The Sun named, Msgr. J. Bruce Jarboe, Official A in the report, was slated to become pastor of a prominent parish, the Church of the Immaculate Conception in Towson. But Archbishop William Lori canceled the transfer the week after The Sun identified Jarboe. He remains pastor of St. Ann in Hagerstown.
